SponsoredWealthsimpleOpen an account — this site may earn a referral bonus at no cost to you.
Retirement Lab
← All guides

Which account should you draw first in retirement?

RRSP, TFSA, or non-registered? The order you withdraw can change your lifetime tax bill by six figures.

Last updated: September 2026 · About 6 min read

Most Canadians retire holding three kinds of savings: RRSPs (taxed when withdrawn), TFSAs (never taxed), and non-registered accounts (capital gains taxed when realized). You need the same spending money either way — but the order you draw from them decides how much tax you pay, both over your lifetime and on your final tax return.

The core tradeoff

It comes down to timing. Draw registered savings early and you pay tax sooner, while your income is often lower — but you shrink the balance that gets taxed on your final return. Draw them last and you defer tax for years, but whatever is left in your RRSP/RRIF at death is taxed as income on one final return, often at the highest rates. There is no universally right answer; it depends on your balances, your other income, and how long the money needs to last.

RRSP first

Drawing the RRSP down deliberately in your 60s — before CPP, OAS, and RRIF minimums push your income up — can keep withdrawals in lower tax brackets. It also melts down the balance that would otherwise be taxed all at once at death. The cost: you pay tax now instead of later, and large early withdrawals can trigger the OAS clawback or reduce income-tested benefits.

TFSA first

TFSA withdrawals are tax-free and don't count as income, so they never trigger the OAS clawback and never reduce GIS. Drawing the TFSA first preserves RRSP room for later — but it leaves the registered balance growing, which usually means a bigger tax bill for your estate. This order tends to win on lifetime tax and lose on total tax once the final return is included.

Non-registered in the mix

Non-registered withdrawals aren't like the other two: only the capital gain is taxable, and only half of it is included in your income. Drawing non-registered savings in years when your other income is low can realize gains cheaply. But gains left unrealized at death face a deemed disposition — the CRA treats you as having sold everything at fair market value.

The tax-smart middle path

The approach our planner tests as "Tax-smart (balanced)" is a bracket-filling heuristic: each year, draw just enough from the RRSP to fill up the current lower tax bracket without spilling into the next one, and fund the rest of your spending from the TFSA and non-registered accounts. It's not a perfect lifetime optimization — no simple rule is — but it usually beats withdrawing blindly from one account until it's empty.

The honest way to decide

Don't pick an order by gut feel. The planner on this site runs your actual numbers through all four withdrawal orders and compares them on the after-tax estate they leave — liquid savings minus the estimated tax at death — so you can see the tradeoff for your situation instead of guessing. That comparison is the whole reason the feature exists: the order with the lowest total tax is frequently not the order that leaves the most behind.

Run your own numbers

The planner tests four withdrawal orders against your situation and shows which one leaves the largest after-tax estate.

Start your plan →

Educational content only — not financial advice. Tax rules and benefit amounts change; confirm current figures with the CRA or a licensed professional before acting. See the Disclaimer.

Sponsored

WealthsimpleOpen a Wealthsimple account — the site may earn a small bonus at no extra cost to you.